It doesn’t matter how much liberals angrily stomp their feet and whine, or how many dumb little debatebro nicknames they make up; it is not, and never will be, fallacious to expect you to apply your standards consistently, or to point out when you’re being a massive hypocrite.
Also, trying to move the goal posts to “it only counts if the ICC says so!” Is so clearly post-hoc and bad faith it’s comical.
Was the US dropping a nuke on Hiroshima a war crime? Or Firebombing entire cities? Unfortunately, “war crimes”, while they have a clear international definition, tend to only apply to whoever loses wars. That’s why the US passed a law requiring military intervention if the ICC tried to arrest an American general.
Here’s Robert McNamara, US Defense Secretary during the Vietnam war, answering that question: “LeMay said if we lost the war that we would have all been prosecuted as war criminals. And I think he’s right. He… and I’d say I… were behaving as war criminals”
Should we ban his books? Sanction people for interviewing him? If we did, we wouldn’t have had that gem of a quote. That entire documentary, mostly composed of interviews of McNamara, is a powerful testament to the dangers of war for humanity. We don’t want a situation where journalists are scared to interview people because of what the government might do to them in response.
Now apply this standard to Western politicians, like Bush, or Biden, or most of them, honestly.
Or Winston “I am highly in favor of using poison gas on uncivilized tribes” Churchill
Yeah, or anyone supporting the genocide in Palestine.
Dam its starting to sound like we just need to get rid of all private press
Removed by mod
It doesn’t matter how much liberals angrily stomp their feet and whine, or how many dumb little debatebro nicknames they make up; it is not, and never will be, fallacious to expect you to apply your standards consistently, or to point out when you’re being a massive hypocrite.
Also, trying to move the goal posts to “it only counts if the ICC says so!” Is so clearly post-hoc and bad faith it’s comical.
Was the US dropping a nuke on Hiroshima a war crime? Or Firebombing entire cities? Unfortunately, “war crimes”, while they have a clear international definition, tend to only apply to whoever loses wars. That’s why the US passed a law requiring military intervention if the ICC tried to arrest an American general.
Here’s Robert McNamara, US Defense Secretary during the Vietnam war, answering that question: “LeMay said if we lost the war that we would have all been prosecuted as war criminals. And I think he’s right. He… and I’d say I… were behaving as war criminals”
Should we ban his books? Sanction people for interviewing him? If we did, we wouldn’t have had that gem of a quote. That entire documentary, mostly composed of interviews of McNamara, is a powerful testament to the dangers of war for humanity. We don’t want a situation where journalists are scared to interview people because of what the government might do to them in response.