

You misunderstand my criticism if you think I’m saying it needs more production. I’m saying the vocals would be better if they sounded less produced. The super clean vocal recording/mixing it uses is a hallmark of pop, not folk.
Folk hooks are also just as catchy as any other genre but this song just isn’t very catchy.
I am not saying you shouldn’t like it, either. I’m glad it resonates with people. I just think it’s mediocrity of being ignored because the message is good and he’s a famous musician. If it was some random dude, no one would be praising it












That is a great observation. I don’t feel like relistening but I’m wondering if it’s the part that made me mention doing another take - it sounded like he got tickled mid sentence