cross-posted from: https://hexbear.net/post/7804222
You can tell this is fake because the USA soldier would shoot the child as well
cross-posted from: https://hexbear.net/post/7804222
You can tell this is fake because the USA soldier would shoot the child as well
I never said anything about orc people. Russian infantry have a reputation for brutality towards civilians and it’s earned. They don’t even really try to hide it. Russian isn’t a “race”. Also, what do you expect when Russia slaughters civilians wholesale and relies almost entirely on “meat wave” tactics. Whether the comparison to orcs is racist can be debated, but it’s clear where it comes from.
My claim about US troops was that they were less terrible. Unfortunately, moral ground troops are hard to find in today’s world. I also said they were better trained at certain things, and I stand by it. That’s not in spite of their many deployments, it’s because of it.
If you want to know about the PLA I suggest asking someone who faught them. Perhaps Japan. If you want more recent, then look at the tens of thousands of Tibetan civilians that were killed - most in labor camps. That’s a bit worse than “collateral damage” from an errant missile. (And yeah, if it was an Israeli missile I think an investigation into how “accidental” it was is warranted.
I was also very critical of IS decisions to go to war in the first place and how they justify it, so what the fuck are you talking about? I’m not “sneaking” anything in. I said what I said because it was precisely what I meant.
Unlike you I don’t pick a team before making my conclusions. There is shit that’s good about the US, and stuff that isn’t. Same is true of China. As for Russia and Israel, I’d love to say something good about them, but they make it pretty tough.
“I’m not racist but-”
but… what? But the thing you wrongly accused me of saying wouldn’t have been racist anyways? That’s not exactly the gotcha you were looking for.
Why is everybody from lemmy.ml so disingenuous in their arguments? It’s almost like you have no legitimate arguments to make.
You immediately proceeded to weasle-word around saying you have no problem with a racist term
This is racist. You are racist.
Sure buddy.
The fact that you think the US is better than Russia says enough about your imperial chauvinism, in my opinion. There’s only one part of this comment I’ll even bother replying to.
You barely even took a sentence to go from “I didn’t call them orc people” to defending calling them orc people. Again, I don’t know who you think you’re fooling with these kinds of rhetorical contortions.
Cancer is better than Russia, so that’s no great achievement. My comment was that there is not much good to say about Russia. I notice you didn’t point out something I missed, you just went straight to an ad hominem.
Yes, my point was both that I didn’t say the thing you claimed was racist, and that it wouldn’t have been racist anyways. No contortion, just you being wrong twice in one statement. And, again, you didn’t bother arguing the point, you just went for yet another ad hominem. That’s three if you count calling me racist.
Yeah, you said they weren’t a race? So it’s not racist to call an ethnicity orcs, because ethnicity is not race? That’s barely an argument, though it is a racist one.
You are being racist. Even if you had said nothing else, the only reason to believe the US is acceptable in any way while Russia isn’t is racism and chauvinism. As I said above, you did say something else and it was racist.
I suspect all this “ad hominem” nonsense is posturing, but if you really think you’re doing some great debate here, don’t bother replying. I have no interest in “debating” with an American chauvinist with a Russia obsession, which I thought I had made clear with my previous replies.
“Russian” is an ethnicity, but it’s also a nationality. Since we are talking specifically about Russian troops, its the nationality being criticized, not the ethnicity. Either way, I never called them orcs, I just pointed out that their behavior invites the comparison. You aren’t much for subtlety, are you?
Back to the ad hominems, and the misquoting. I never said the US is “acceptable”. I have only spoken in favor of a single attribute of US ground troops, and I’ve been quite clear that there are many aspects of the US that are entirely unacceptable. The current war with Iran is entirely so, as have been many similar adventures.
There is only so “great” one can be at debating when the “arguments” are as bad and fabricated as yours.
Yeah, you just went on a whole roundabout justification of other people doing it, that’s very different. Here’s a hint: someone who wasn’t racist would have said “I never called anyone an orc” instead of doing that.
No, you’ve just made it clear that you can accept its existence and not the existence of Russia.
You uncritically repeated a single attribute of US ground troop propaganda, actually.
This isn’t a “debate”, I thought I had been pretty clear about that. I don’t care to “debate” with someone who thinks America is better than Russia.
LOL, falling back on “That’s propaganda!”. The one lame trope you had yet to pull out. Well, calling any argument or fact that favors the west “propaganda” is also propaganda so there! I sure got you good.
It’s getting really old pointing this but, no, I didn’t say that either. If I tell someone that their behavior is unacceptable, that does not imply that their “existence” is unacceptable. To whatever extent you think I need to say it, I will say that Russia’s continued existence is just fine with me. However, I’m done with this bullshit. You win, or whatever.
OK, you can continue to believe the US has particularly moral ground troops whereas Russians are like orcs.
As I said, this isn’t a debate. But I agree with you that we have nothing to say to each other.
And yet your jaw keeps flipping.