Honestly seeing the before and after just makes me want it to be a changing weather system. Sorry for the scope creep suggestion. 😅

Looks pretty foggin good. Just a light touch of it. And not a soupy overdone mess. As is so often tempting to do.

Okay, here’s my take: that’s some good looking fog. Like on a scale of 1 to fog, that’s like heavy mist. But here’s the thing: every time I play a game with fog, I think to myself “I wish that wasn’t there.” If you’re going to use the fog, give it purpose. A great example of bad fog is Elden Ring. Example 1: Consecrated Snowfield. Boring garbage that only serves to hide how empty the area is. Example 2: Gravesite Plain in SOTE. Takes an already lackluster area and just makes it even moreso with a big wall of white.

Ironically, Elden Ring also has an example of good fog: Mountaintop of the Giants, Frozen Lake. The fog is generated by Borealis and clears when you defeat him, meaning you’re not faced with a permanently boring area in a primarily visual medium. It adds a cinematic intro for the boss as well as an added layer of difficulty for the fight. This is fog with purpose and how it should be implemented.

The image is of low quality but the results look good. What is this dark blob over the rocks in the image with fog, above the rocks? Is that an artefact of your fog or is it meant to be there?

Looks like the fog only applies to close objects. True fog would obscure far objects as well. As it is now, off is better.

As a casual gamer with no special knowledge about graphics, I like the one with fog! As long as it doesn’t lower fps of course :>

I read “frogs” and was confused by the picture. The preview looks nice! But it’s missing frogs now.

To me it looks better without fog, but the fog doesn’t look bad at all, I just like it slightly more without fog. Imo best would be if both states where in the game, if performance allows it. Sometimes (more) foggy, sometimes not, depending on time of day or in game events.

In the fog picture there is also some dark sky between trees (along the upper edge, about 40% from the left) that suddenly jumps out, I don’t think that patch should be that dark if the player is standing inside a cloud.

Looks great. Only problem I see with it is that the skybox isnt treated the same as the other geometry creating a border between the trees and sky.

now the only thing missing from your game is froggy weather

The fog reminded me of playing pubg, which cycles fog. (and weather) The maps become slightly different to play with high intensity fog. I like it, I think it looks good.

I am trying to get your feedbacks

The image is a little pixelated in my client, but I like the fog! It adds depth to the world and it can help make weather effects more convincing

I feel the fog makes it feel very atmospheric. Without fog feels like a crisp winter day, with fog feels like a more unnerving experience.

Thanks