painting a picture of us as claiming nobody died at all on June 4th
People are actually constantly claiming this on this platform. You’re again being disingenuous by claiming otherwise or have your eyes closed.
The whole “tank man wasn’t murdered” talking point is a pathetic attempt to deny the entire incident by re-focusing the incident on tank man and completely ignoring the events which lead up to it.
You’re entirely wrong. People say that nobody died in Tian’anmen Square, which is true, even the ever-biased Wikipedia agrees that dispersal of the square was peaceful. You’re reading people denying the western myth of tanks running over 10,000 people on the square itself as denying any killings by the PLA on June 4th,1989. Post evidence of the claims you believe exist, or stop with your historical denialism.
The whole “tank man wasn’t murdered” thing is a pathetic attempt to deny the entire incident by re-focusing the incident on tank man and completely ignoring the events which lead up to it.
No, it’s to point out how the west teaches a mythologized version of events by focusing on one of its most iconic moments, and showing that it doesn’t at all align with the western version of events. If anything, communists are the ones that actually know what the protests were about in the month leading up to it in April and May, CIA involvement with the student leaders through Operation Yellowbird, and so forth, because whenever we claim to support the PRC anti-communists inevitably wield the mythologized version of events like a club against us, which we have to dispel over and over again.
You’re pathetic. I JUST explained the talking point to you and how pointless it was and you in your infinite wisdom knee jerked yourself into posting it.
I don’t think it’s pathetic to combat misinformation that you’re spreading, without even having the decency to provide evidence backing your claims up. You have a knee-jerk reaction to deny anything that disagrees with your internal narrative.
Claim A: 10,000 people were killed in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989
Claim B, Part 1: No, nobody died in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989.
Claim B, Part 2: Hundreds of people died around Beijing on June 4th, 1989, including dozens of PLA officers lynched and firebombed, as well as hundreds of rioters.
Both parts of Claim B are intrinsically tied together, but you read it as distinct claims made by different people to justify your absurd claims.
Nope, incorrect. You’re claiming communists that dispel myths about June 4th are practicing “historical denialism” by doing so, and are now moving the goalposts because you know I’m correct about what happened. You’re inventing a motive to suit what you already feel about communists, and don’t even have the decency to make a consistent and clear claim with evidence, just vague posturing and libel.
The only one in this thread practicing denialism and revisionism is yourself, though, for the purposes of discrediting communists and communism in general.
Which of these claims do you think is closest to the truth, and which do you think communists are positing?
Claim A: 10,000 people were killed in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989
Claim B, Part 1: No, nobody died in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989.
Claim B, Part 2: Hundreds of people died around Beijing on June 4th, 1989, including dozens of PLA officers lynched and firebombed, as well as hundreds of rioters.
Keep in mind that in my view, as someone that speaks with communists all the time, I have only ever seen communists make Claim B, either in seperate comments or (usually) together.
People are actually constantly claiming this on this platform. You’re again being disingenuous by claiming otherwise or have your eyes closed.
The whole “tank man wasn’t murdered” talking point is a pathetic attempt to deny the entire incident by re-focusing the incident on tank man and completely ignoring the events which lead up to it.
You’re entirely wrong. People say that nobody died in Tian’anmen Square, which is true, even the ever-biased Wikipedia agrees that dispersal of the square was peaceful. You’re reading people denying the western myth of tanks running over 10,000 people on the square itself as denying any killings by the PLA on June 4th,1989. Post evidence of the claims you believe exist, or stop with your historical denialism.
No, it’s to point out how the west teaches a mythologized version of events by focusing on one of its most iconic moments, and showing that it doesn’t at all align with the western version of events. If anything, communists are the ones that actually know what the protests were about in the month leading up to it in April and May, CIA involvement with the student leaders through Operation Yellowbird, and so forth, because whenever we claim to support the PRC anti-communists inevitably wield the mythologized version of events like a club against us, which we have to dispel over and over again.
You’re pathetic. I JUST explained the talking point to you and how pointless it was and you in your infinite wisdom knee jerked yourself into posting it.
I don’t think it’s pathetic to combat misinformation that you’re spreading, without even having the decency to provide evidence backing your claims up. You have a knee-jerk reaction to deny anything that disagrees with your internal narrative.
Claim A: 10,000 people were killed in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989
Claim B, Part 1: No, nobody died in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989.
Claim B, Part 2: Hundreds of people died around Beijing on June 4th, 1989, including dozens of PLA officers lynched and firebombed, as well as hundreds of rioters.
Both parts of Claim B are intrinsically tied together, but you read it as distinct claims made by different people to justify your absurd claims.
You’re deflecting by focusing on the square and not the pile of mutilated corpses because you cannot defend that.
Lol show me this pile
Nope, incorrect. You’re claiming communists that dispel myths about June 4th are practicing “historical denialism” by doing so, and are now moving the goalposts because you know I’m correct about what happened. You’re inventing a motive to suit what you already feel about communists, and don’t even have the decency to make a consistent and clear claim with evidence, just vague posturing and libel.
Incorrect. I like communists. I like communism. I don’t like denialism.
I would like to be more involved but I cannot in good conscience join any group that participates in denialism and revisionism.
The only one in this thread practicing denialism and revisionism is yourself, though, for the purposes of discrediting communists and communism in general.
Which of these claims do you think is closest to the truth, and which do you think communists are positing?
Claim A: 10,000 people were killed in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989
Claim B, Part 1: No, nobody died in Tian’anmen Square on June 4th, 1989.
Claim B, Part 2: Hundreds of people died around Beijing on June 4th, 1989, including dozens of PLA officers lynched and firebombed, as well as hundreds of rioters.
Keep in mind that in my view, as someone that speaks with communists all the time, I have only ever seen communists make Claim B, either in seperate comments or (usually) together.
Anybody know a forum for actual leftist?
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
And now you’ve been reduced to the point of lying through your teeth